logo

Norway's multi-billion-kroner naval vessel procurement – opportunities, risks and legal challenges

The Norwegian Defence Materiel Agency (FMA) has published a contract notice for the construction of up to 20 standardised vessels for the Royal Norwegian Navy and Coast Guard (P1118). The first stage will involve a prequalification process based on the requirements and criteria set out in the qualification documents. The remaining tender documents have not yet been published and will be provided to suppliers that are prequalified and invited to submit tenders.

The procurement is reserved for Norwegian suppliers and is planned to be divided into two parts: a naval contract (14 vessels for the Royal Norwegian Navy and allied partners) and a Coast Guard contract (six vessels, with an option for four additional oceangoing Coast Guard vessels). While the main customers will be the Norwegian Navy and Coast Guard, with deliveries scheduled between 2030 and 2038, the British and Lithuanian navies may also become customers under the naval contract.

The vessels are to be constructed at Norwegian shipyards, although parts of the hull construction may be carried out at third country steel fabrication yards. This represents a substantial order for Norwegian shipyards and is expected to generate significant, long-term activity throughout the relevant supply chain.

Provided that the vessels prove successful and the project progresses as planned, other NATO countries may well decide to join the program, in addition to the United Kingdom and Lithuania, which are already involved. For example, Germany, through TKMS, has substantial outstanding industrial cooperation obligations towards Norway following Norway's decision to purchase a total of six Type 212CD submarines from the German shipbuilder.

Our key observations on how FMA has structured the procurement are set out below.

Competition law and public procurement considerations

Suppliers may apply for prequalification for both contracts and submit tenders for both. However, as a starting point the same supplier cannot be awarded both contracts. If a supplier submits the winning tender for the naval contract, its tender for the Coast Guard contract will be rejected, regardless of its merits. This clearly indicates that FMA considers the naval contract to be the priority here.

A supplier also cannot be awarded both contracts through participation in a consortium or by acting as a supporting entity on which another tenderer relies to satisfy the qualification requirements. If a supplier participates in multiple tenders in this manner, its tender for the Coast Guard contract will not be considered.

However, there is no prohibition on submitting an individual tender while also acting as a subcontractor in another tender, provided that the subcontractor is not relied upon by the other tenderer to satisfy the qualification requirements. FMA has therefore not imposed a blanket prohibition on involvement in more than one contract.

In addition, FMA has the discretion to find it acceptable for parties to participate in more than one consortium if it considers this "necessary to ensure effective competition or a sound and satisfactory procurement process". Given participation in this procurement will no doubt be highly resource-intensive and entail considerable risk, it is reasonable to question whether a party would ever be willing to participate in more than one consortium, particularly as it is impossible to know in advance whether FMA will exercise its discretion under the exemption provision.

Furthermore, if the same parties participate in several consortia, this could itself restrict competition – precisely the outcome FMA evidently seeks to avoid. Competition law concerns may also arise (i) where a consortium includes more parties than are necessary to submit the tender, thereby preventing those (surplus) parties from participating in other consortia that could increase the overall number of bidders, and (ii) In connection with the exchange of information, as parties participating in multiple consortia (whether as a tenderer in several consortia or as both a tenderer and a subcontractor) may gain access to commercially sensitive tender information relating to competing bids. Suppliers must therefore carefully consider how to ensure compliance with competition law during the bid process.

In this context, it is also noteworthy that FMA has indicated that compensation will be provided for participation in the tender process. However, the detailed terms and conditions of such compensation will only be disclosed in the tender documents issued to suppliers following prequalification.

In practice, suppliers must decide whether to participate in one or more tenders before the deadline for submitting requests to participate, and therefore without knowing the amount of compensation available. This uncertainty may also influence their decisions regarding participation in multiple bids.

Contractual considerations

The supplier will assume overall responsibility for the turnkey delivery of the vessels, and the shipbuilding contracts will, "as a starting point", be based on fixed prices.

It remains unclear whether the supplier will be required to assume the risks and liabilities associated with design work already completed. Nevertheless, a fixed-price approach may appear ambitious, given that the supplier will have overall responsibility for delivery and will be required to enter into a subcontract with FMA's appointed ship designer, based on prices already agreed.

There will also be an obligation to cooperate with the supplier awarded the other contract to achieve the greatest possible degree of standardisation, both in relation to design and the procurement of equipment and systems. However the requirement for each shipbuilding contractor to negotiate its own contractual terms with FMA's design supplier, potentially resulting in different contractual arrangements, may create interface issues in the standardisation process between the two contractors.

The contracts will follow a structure based on the standard Ship25 shipbuilding contract, with substantial amendments to accommodate the particular characteristics of the procurement and certain specific requirements applicable to defence contracts. It will be interesting to see whether FMA makes use of any of the new opt-in provisions introduced by Ship25, including the shipyard's ability to limit its design liability, and whether price adjustment mechanisms will be permitted. Such measures could reduce suppliers' exposure to cost overruns and facilitate more competitive pricing.

The procurement also provides for the use of refund guarantees to secure advance instalment payments. Although this is a standard requirement in most shipbuilding contracts, it is worth noting that the requirement for bank guarantees, combined with a potentially extensive construction programme and other security requirements, could result in significant guarantee costs for suppliers.

Security-classified procurement

Another important consideration for bidders is that this is a security-classified procurement. The tender process will therefore involve requirements under the Norwegian Security Act, including the obligation to enter into a security agreement with FMA. The information currently made available to prospective suppliers is classified only as "BEGRENSET" (RESTRICTED). However, it is envisaged that the successful bidder will be required to obtain security clearance under Section 9-3 of the Norwegian Security Act and that they will have access to information classified as "KONFIDENSIELT" (CONFIDENTIAL). That being the case, the forthcoming amendments to the investment screening rules in Chapter 10 of the Norwegian Security Act will become relevant, whereby even a relatively minor change in ownership at shareholder level (direct or indirect) of the supplier may become subject to investment control scrutiny by the Ministry of Defence/the Norwegian National Security Agency. Suppliers should therefore consider whether these requirements may affect their long-term strategies for attracting investment or divesting parts of their businesses.

Suppliers should also assess whether their organisations and systems are adequately prepared for any necessary supplier security clearance under Section 9-3 of the Norwegian Security Act. This includes considering the nationality of board members and senior management, the likelihood of those individuals obtaining the necessary personnel security clearances, and any other preparatory measures and implications associated with entering into a security agreement.

Photo: Edward V. Coates / Forsvaret