Climate Case II: The State Loses – Oil Companies Can Continue Operations

Sitting as a Grand Chamber, the Supreme Court held, by a majority of 6–5, that the State’s decisions to uphold the PDO approvals were invalid due to procedural errors. The State therefore lost the case. However, the Supreme Court clarified that the judgment has legal effect only in relation to the State, not the oil companies concerned, and that their approvals for development and operation remain valid.
The central issue in the case has been the requirements for assessing the environmental impacts of a proposed oil and gas development project, particularly its climate impacts. This ultimately came down to the interpretation of the EU Environmental Impact Assessment Directive (EIA Directive), which has been incorporated into Norwegian law. The State’s original position was that the EIA Directive only requires an assessment of the climate impacts arising from the implementation of the specific project, rather than those resulting from the consumption of the oil and gas produced and exported (combustion emissions).
While appealing the decisions of the District Court and the Court of Appeal, the authorities also amended the environmental impact assessment requirements to include combustion emissions. The operators of the three fields subsequently prepared supplementary assessments in accordance with the updated requirements. In this way, the State took steps to remedy the procedural errors. A key question before the Supreme Court was therefore what requirements the EIA Directive imposes regarding the assessment of a project's climate impacts, and whether the three projects could now be regarded as having been sufficiently assessed, thereby remedying the procedural errors.
The majority of the Supreme Court justices held that the operators’ assessments should have taken into account the total combustion emissions from Norwegian petroleum activities (cumulative emissions), which they had failed to do. The same deficiency affected the Ministry of Energy’s overall assessment of the environmental impact assessments. The majority had no doubt that this constituted a procedural error satisfying the requirement of potential influence on the outcome under Section 41 of the Norwegian Public Administration Act. The majority therefore found that the State’s decision not to reverse the original PDO approvals, on the grounds that the procedural errors had been remedied, was invalid.
The State must now obtain new assessments from the operators that take cumulative emissions into account. These assessments must be subject to public consultation, after which the State must assess the impacts of the cumulative emissions before reconsidering the PDO approvals.
However, the State was successful on two important subsidiary issues. First, the Supreme Court clarified that operators are not required to describe and assess the specific consequences of the temperature increases expected to result from the emissions. This is a useful clarification for operators, who would otherwise have faced the difficult task of determining the appropriate scope of their assessments.
Second, the Supreme Court stated that the State is not obliged to assess combustion emissions against remaining carbon budgets. This is a particularly important clarification, as the opposite conclusion could have been interpreted as imposing a substantive limitation on the State’s discretion to decide whether to approve a PDO. The Supreme Court was unanimous on both points.
A central issue in the case concerns the effect of the judgment on the licence holders under the PDO approvals. The licence holders are not parties to the proceedings, which were brought against the State. The Supreme Court emphasised that a judgment is legally binding only on the parties to the proceedings, pursuant to Section 19-15, first paragraph, of the Norwegian Dispute Act. It further stated that a judgment declaring a decision invalid entails no more than an obligation on the public administration to reconsider the matter.
The administration must then determine whether the approvals should be revoked or upheld, provided that the procedural errors are rectified. In this regard, the Supreme Court also referred to the recent judgment in the Førdefjord case, which addressed a similar issue. As the judgment has legal effect only in relation to the State, the licence holders may continue their activities under the existing approvals.
The Court also addressed the requirements under EEA law for remedying procedural errors involving breaches of EEA law. Reference was made to the advisory opinion obtained from the EFTA Court by the Court of Appeal, which established that revocation or suspension of permits is not an absolute requirement for compliance with the duty of sincere cooperation under the EEA Agreement, and that subsequent approval is also possible.
The minority disagreed that there is a requirement to assess emissions from the specific project against cumulative combustion emissions from the Norwegian continental shelf. In their view, there was insufficient legal basis for imposing such a requirement, which would be based on emissions from a single sector in a single country, whereas the project's impact on the global climate is what ultimately matters. The minority concluded that no procedural errors had occurred and that the PDO approvals were valid.
Our assessment: It was expected that the Supreme Court would clarify the scope of the obligation to assess the impacts of combustion emissions arising from development projects on the Norwegian continental shelf. That the Court, by a narrow majority, ultimately adopted a stricter interpretation than the State had argued for is therefore not particularly surprising.
The clarifications that the assessments need not address the specific consequences of the temperature increases expected to result from the emissions, and that the State is not obliged to assess combustion emissions against remaining carbon budgets, are both important.
The specific guidance provided by the judgment in relation to the three PDO approvals will also be highly valuable for future projects. Many will also take note of the Court’s clear guidance on the much-debated question of the effect of judgments declaring administrative decisions invalid on third parties.
For the industry, and particularly the licence holders concerned, the judgment is likely to provide welcome clarification and greater certainty for their continued operations. Environmental organisations will present the judgment as a victory. However, as long as the licence holders concerned can continue their operations, there is reason to believe that environmental organisations will seek new opportunities to challenge oil and gas activities through the courts.


